Last night Jimmy Fallon did a skit called Tebowie. (You can watch it here if you like.) The skit is really pretty brilliant, combining Tim Tebow and David Bowie into one character. And I’ll admit I laughed, especially during Jesus’s response. But it calls to mind something that’s been bugging me for a long time: are we even capable of talking about Tim Tebow without talking about religion?
To me, TIm Tebow is a guy who’s managed to lead the Denver Broncos into the playoffs in a year in which that seemed a relatively remote possibility. I think he’s a great – albeit young – quarterback. He makes some smart decisions out there; he makes some pretty bad ones. Just like just about any other non-Cleveland second-year quarterback. But watching him play is exciting because Tim gets excited. When he’s on a roll, his smile is brilliant and he’s clearly loving his job and his life.
And he doesn’t quit. I’ve seen plenty of quarterbacks throw in the towel halfway through the fourth quarter. (Here’s yet another good place to mention Cleveland.) Football is all about fighting until that last second, but Tim Tebow is just about the only player I’ve seen who believes in fighting until the end. He’s been rewarded for it, too, with four overtime wins so far this season.
So there it is. Tim Tebow: a great young player who doesn’t give up.
Oh, and maybe you’ve heard, he also believes in Jesus Christ.
Everyone from Shannon Sharpe to the aforementioned Jimmy Fallon seemingly can’t mention Tim Tebow without also mentioning his faith. No one – at least no one at that level – outright makes fun of him, but they seem to want to turn him over under a microscope. To try to figure out if this Jesus-thing has any real significance. To see if maybe he’s winning games because God really is on his side.
Even actual reporters are missing the point. The Baltimore Sun editorial indulges in the purported significance of Tebow’s 316 passing yards for 31.6 yards-per-completion, the significance being John 3:16: For God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life. The Sun’s indulgence meant to poke fun at said indulgences, ironically. But that’s only after writing the thing that bugs me the most about the whole Tebow phenomenon: “Tebow is devoted to his faith in a very public way.”
Yes, Tim Tebow prays. Yes, Tim Tebow thanks God. Yes, Tim Tebow wears bible verses on his face. But to say that he is “very public” about his faith is a complete fabrication.
In every single interview I’ve seen with Tim Tebow this year, the subject of his faith has, in fact, come up. And in every single one of them, it’s been the other person who brought it up. Tim Tebow talks about his faith because people ask him about it. Tim Tebow is public about his faith in exactly the same way and you and I are public about our noses: he has it. People notice. No one asks about our noses because almost everyone has one. Everyone asks about Tebow’s faith because few people have it, at least at that level. I don’t believe what he believes, but I wish I could believe in something to the degree that Tim Tebow does.
Which, I think, is the reason behind the fascination. They don’t want to know what Tim believes; they want to know how he believes. And so strongly. How he can do God’s good work in these times. And that – that - is the real faith. Anyone can believe in anything when you’re winning games. It takes real faith to believe when you’re down two touchdowns in the fourth against Tom Brady. The reason we turn Tim Tebow over under a microscope isn’t that he believes; it’s that we don’t.

